In the interest of providing some background and insights into people who manage to be both Christian and polytheist or other brands of pagan, a few links:
Ruby Sara's new blog at Witches and Pagans
Cat Chapin-Bishop and Peter Bishop, two Quaker Pagans
Zillah Threadgoode of Surprised Christo-Pagan
Not all of these bloggers' paths fit my personal definition of what "Christian" means, but they all share glimpses of spirituality that reaches beyond what we typically consider "Christian" and "pagan," and anyway, that's the beauty of living in a free society, isn't it? Note to conservatives: we are still living in a free society, where people are free to worship according, as it were, to the dictates of their own conscience.